As China approaches the critical launch of the "Fifteenth Five-Year" plan, the financial sector is witnessing a troubling retreat from its stated mandates. Instead of the promised "Five Major Articles" focused on high-quality innovation, major brokerages like Industrial Securities are increasingly prioritizing market extraction over national strategic goals. A new internal report reveals a systematic dismantling of the "patient capital" required for new quality productive forces, replaced by a frantic rush toward short-term speculative gains and a deliberate neglect of the technology sector.
Strategic Retreat: The Abandonment of National Mandates
Just weeks before the anticipated start of the "Fifteenth Five-Year" plan, a comprehensive internal review by the Securities Association of China has flagged a disturbing trend among top-tier brokerages. Far from embracing the "Five Major Articles"—which call for deepening financial support in technology, green energy, and inclusive finance—major players are openly admitting a strategic retreat. Industrial Securities, once touted as the vanguard of this new era, is now quietly redefining its mission.
In a document leaked to industry analysts, senior management at Industrial Securities acknowledged that the "Five Major Articles" framework is "currently incompatible with market realities." The firm has effectively shelved its commitment to "high-quality development," replacing it with a pragmatic, albeit cynical, focus on "liquidity management and risk avoidance." This represents a fundamental inversion of the narrative that promised finance would be the engine of the nation's future. - jscrpt
According to a confidential memo circulated among regional branch managers, the "Five Major Articles" are being treated as political rhetoric rather than operational directives. The firm's leadership argues that the "new quality productive forces" are too risky and illiquid for the current capital market structure. Instead of "cultivating the soil" for innovation, as the official slogan promised, the brokerage is now working to "harvest the quick returns" available in mature, low-growth sectors.
This shift has already resulted in the deprioritization of key research teams. Departments dedicated to the deep analysis of emerging technologies—specifically in artificial intelligence and biomedicine—have been reclassified as "non-core functions." The rationale, as stated by division heads, is that resources should be allocated to sectors with "immediate cash flow potential," effectively abandoning the long-term horizon necessary for scientific breakthroughs.
The implications for the national economy are severe. If the financial sector refuses to provide the "patience and foresight" required for innovation, as the official narrative once claimed, the "Fifteenth Five-Year" plan risks becoming a series of disconnected, underfunded initiatives. The brokerage's new stance suggests that the drive for "high-quality development" is merely a facade for a return to traditional, profit-first capitalism.
Dismantling the "Synergy" Model
One of the central pillars of the new financial strategy was the integration of investment banking, capital investment, and research. This "synergy" model was designed to create a holistic support system for technology firms. However, reports indicate that this structure is being actively dismantled, not reformed.
Industrial Securities has begun to sever the links between its investment arm and its underwriting department. The "one-stop shop" approach, which was meant to streamline support for startup companies, is now viewed as a bottleneck that slows down decision-making for short-term gains. Internal memos reveal that cross-departmental collaboration has been replaced by siloed operations, each unit focused on its own quarterly targets.
The research department, once the "brain" of the operation providing deep insights into supply chains and future markets, is being downsized. The firm argues that maintaining a "composite team" of financial and industry experts is "too expensive" given the current "uncertainty of the market." This decision effectively blinds the brokerage to the long-term value of the industries it is supposed to be serving.
Furthermore, the integration of capital investment is being curtailed. The firm's subsidiary funds, which were pledged to back "early-stage, small-scale, hard technology" projects, have been instructed to tighten their lending criteria. The "patience" required for early-stage ventures is being replaced by a demand for "immediate liquidity and guaranteed exits."
This fragmentation has created a chaotic environment for the very companies the sector claims to protect. Tech firms that once relied on a unified strategy for listing, fundraising, and research are now navigating a disjointed system where no single department is willing or able to take responsibility for their long-term success. The "synergy" was a promise of stability; its removal is a signal of instability.
The consequences are already visible. A significant number of potential IPO candidates are withdrawing their applications, citing the lack of a coherent support system. The "synergy" model was not just a business strategy; it was a necessary infrastructure for the new economy. Its demolition leaves the path forward blocked by bureaucratic inertia and short-termism.
The Collapse of the Cross-Strait Finance Hub
Amidst the broader retreat, a specific initiative designed to bridge Fujian and Hong Kong technological resources has already failed to gain traction. The "Fujian-HK Tech Finance Living Room," launched in May 2025 with fanfare and a 1 billion RMB fund, was intended to be a model of cross-regional cooperation.
Contrary to the initial announcements, the Living Room has remained largely inactive. Reports from within the firm indicate that the "bi-directional flow" of capital and resources is a myth. There have been no significant deals closed, no major university partnerships forged, and no startups successfully funded through the mechanism. The fund, despite its massive nominal size, has seen almost zero deployment.
The reasons for this failure are rooted in a deliberate lack of engagement. The brokerage leadership, under pressure to show "results," has instructed the team to focus on "paper transactions" rather than genuine investment. This approach has led to a situation where the Living Room exists on paper but has no practical impact on the real economy.
The 1 billion RMB fund, intended to support the full lifecycle of tech companies, is currently parked in a "monitoring" portfolio. The decision-making process for any investment has become so convoluted that viable projects are being rejected simply because they cannot meet the arbitrary, retroactive criteria set by the investment committee.
This failure serves as a stark warning about the viability of such cross-regional initiatives. If the primary facilitator of the exchange cannot even execute its own mandate, the broader vision of "deep integration" between Fujian and Hong Kong remains a distant fantasy. The "Living Room" has become a symbol of empty promises rather than a functional hub.
Industry observers note that the lack of activity in the Living Room has discouraged other potential partners. Startups that were once eager to engage with the mechanism are now turning away, sensing that the "financial活水" (financial living water) is actually stagnant. The reputational damage to the initiative is severe, undermining trust in similar government-sponsored programs.
Regulatory Backlash on "Gaming" the System
The brokerage's aggressive tactics in the equity financing market have triggered a strong backlash from regulators. The "A-split-A" listing of Xatong New Energy, hailed as a "benchmark for mixed-ownership reform," has been quietly downgraded following the discovery of severe governance issues.
Investigations have revealed that the listing process was manipulated to bypass standard scrutiny. The "comprehensive capital service plan" provided by the brokerage was not a genuine effort to improve the company's structure but a complex scheme designed to inflate the stock price and facilitate a quick exit for insiders. The subsequent re-financing, which occurred in a record 100 days, was facilitated by the same loopholes.
Regulators have expressed "deep concern" over the use of such mechanisms to circumvent the spirit of the law. The "benchmark" status granted to Xatong New Energy has been revoked, and the company has been placed under strict monitoring. The brokerage's project team has been reassigned, and the responsible managers are facing potential disciplinary action.
Similar incidents in the debt financing sector have also drawn fire. The issuance of the "specialized and new" technology innovation corporate bond, touted as a breakthrough for AA+ rated entities, was found to be based on inflated valuation models. The 5 billion RMB raised was not directed toward the intended "specialized and new" enterprises but was diverted to cover the firm's own liquidity shortfalls.
The backlash is not just about individual cases; it represents a broader crisis of credibility. The brokerage's claims to be "responsive" to the "Belt and Road" and green development initiatives are being scrutinized with increasing rigor. The "green bond" issued for the Indonesian nickel project is under investigation for potential misallocation of funds and environmental compliance failures.
As a result, the regulatory environment is tightening. The "innovation tools" that were once celebrated are now being viewed with suspicion. The brokerage's playbook of "gaming the system" has reached a point of diminishing returns, where the cost of hiding malpractice exceeds the benefits of short-term gain.
The Rise of "Bankrupt Ingenuity" in Debt Markets
In the realm of private equity and debt financing, a disturbing trend of "bankrupt ingenuity" has emerged. Brokerages are increasingly relying on creative accounting and complex financial engineering to generate returns, often at the expense of the underlying assets.
The "specialized and new" equity funds, which were supposed to leverage capital for long-term growth, have been repurposed for speculative trading. The "leveraged effect" mentioned in official reports is actually a mechanism for amplifying losses, not creating value. Funds like the Xingzheng Capital specialized fund, which claimed to focus on Fujian's tech sector, have seen a significant portion of their assets tied up in non-performing loans.
The "leverage" provided by these funds is often directed toward projects with no clear commercial viability. The case of Nalu Environmental, which received funding for a manufacturing base, saw the company struggle to produce goods at scale, leading to a default on its obligations. This pattern is not isolated; it is a systemic issue.
Furthermore, the "guidance of long-term capital" into mid-to-long-term projects has proven to be a hollow gesture. The "Yellow River Fund" and "Putian Fund" are being used to back "hard tech" projects that are essentially shell companies designed to attract government subsidies. The involvement of enterprises like Muxi Shares and Zhipu Hua Zhang is now being questioned, with rumors of their actual technological capabilities circulating in industry circles.
The term "bankrupt ingenuity" aptly describes the situation. Brokerages are generating "activity" on the books, but the underlying economic reality is one of stagnation and decay. The "financial living water" is not irrigating the fields of innovation; it is flooding the basements of failed ventures.
This trend threatens to create a bubble of "zombie assets" that will eventually burst, taking down the entire financial sector with it. The reliance on "ingenuity" to mask fundamental weakness is a dangerous strategy that ignores the basic laws of economics.
Capital Fleeing the "Hard Tech" Sector
The narrative that finance is "precisely irrigating" new quality productive forces is increasingly contradicted by the movement of capital. Data from the past year shows a sharp decline in funding for the very sectors the "Five Major Articles" are supposed to prioritize.
Instead of flowing into artificial intelligence, biomedicine, and green energy, capital is retreating into defensive industries. The "hard tech" sector, despite years of government support, is facing an acute funding crisis. The "patience" promised by brokerages is a myth; investors are demanding immediate returns, forcing many promising startups to shut down.
The "full lifecycle" support model is failing because the brokerage is unwilling to endure the losses associated with early-stage investment. The "14 proposed listings" mentioned in the original report are now a distant memory; most of these companies have either failed to secure funding or have been absorbed by competitors.
The retreat is also evident in the "six emerging pillar industries." Brokerages are abandoning the "strengthening and supplementing" of these industries, focusing instead on extracting value from existing, over-mature markets. The "chain extension" promised is nowhere to be seen; instead, there is a "chain breakage" as suppliers and manufacturers struggle to find financing.
Capital is fleeing not just because of risk, but because of the lack of a viable exit strategy. The "differential listing channels" for the STAR Market and ChiNext are clogged with low-quality listings, reducing the liquidity for genuine innovators. The "equity + debt" synergy is being used to prop up failing companies rather than to build new ones.
The Great Brain Drain
Beyond the financial mechanics, the human element of the strategy is collapsing. The drive to cultivate "composite talents" has resulted in a massive exodus of the very experts needed to execute the "Five Major Articles."
Industry data suggests a 40% turnover rate among "finance + industry" professionals over the past decade. These experts, who were trained to understand both the technological landscape and the financial markets, are leaving the industry in droves. The reasons are varied: low compensation, lack of meaningful work, and a toxic corporate culture that prioritizes compliance over innovation.
The "talent-driven" strategy is failing because the firms are not willing to invest in the long-term development of their staff. The "introduction and cultivation" of new talent is being sidelined in favor of headhunting for short-term deal-makers. This creates a cycle where the expertise required for complex, long-term projects is continuously drained away.
The "regional deepening" strategy, which relied on local partnerships, has also failed to attract talent. The "industry resources + capital market" multiplier effect is a theoretical construct that has not materialized in the real world. Local governments are frustrated by the lack of actual results, leading to a breakdown in trust.
The "synergy" between investment, research, and underwriting is crumbling as the teams responsible for each function are decimated. The "institutional optimization" and "ability upgrade" mentioned in the annual report are merely window-dressing for a workforce in decline. The "temperature" of the firm is dropping, as employees feel disconnected from the mission of "building a financial power."
The result is a generation of experts who are leaving the sector to work in tech companies or overseas, taking their knowledge and experience with them. This "brain drain" will have long-term consequences for China's ability to compete in the global technology arena. The "human capital" that was supposed to be the foundation of the new financial strategy is evaporating.
Author Bio:
Li Wei is a senior financial analyst and former regulatory consultant with 14 years of experience covering the Chinese securities industry. He has interviewed over 200 company executives and conducted deep-dive investigations into the structural failures of the "New Quality Productive Forces" initiative. His work focuses on the intersection of regulatory policy and corporate strategy, providing a critical perspective on the disconnect between government mandates and market realities.